
Marketplace Physical Therapy increases visit volume by 14.8% while slashing admin time with Penciled
Marketplace partnered with Penciled to automate front office tasks like scheduling initial exams, booking out plan of care visits, automating confirmations, and filling last-minute cancellations.
Overview
Marketplace Physical Therapy, a 43 provider group on WebPT, increased visit volume while lowering administrative burden by automating front office operations with Penciled. Marketplace leveraged Penciled's automated initial exam scheduling, plan of care compliance system, responsive confirmations, and waitlist. Marketplace booked 2400+ visits through Penciled in one month, achieved a 14.8% increase in volumes, and reduced inbound calls by 27%.
At a glance
- Organization: Marketplace Physical Therapy and Wellness Center
- Region: Los Angeles area
- Team: 43 providers across 5 locations (Redlands, Riverside, Beaumont, Chino, Corona)
- Core operational challenge: sustain growth and patient experience as labor costs rise and reimbursements tighten
- Primary goals: keep schedules full, reduce no-shows/cancellations, and lower the cost of administrative work without sacrificing quality
- Results (first clinic fully rolled out on Penciled):
- +14.8% increase in total visit volume (3-month average at Riverwalk)
- 50%+ of visits scheduled automatically through Penciled for first clinic deployed (targeting 80%+ in 2026)
- 90+ hours of administrative time saved (conservative estimate at one location)
- 27% drop in call volume (patients resolving more without calling)
About Marketplace's team




Marketplace Physical Therapy and Wellness Center is one of the leading providers of physical therapy services in the Los Angeles region. Their organization includes 43 providers across five clinics in Redlands, Riverside, Beaumont, Chino, and Corona.
To operate efficiently at scale, Marketplace uses a centralized operations team responsible for patient processing across locations-especially the workflows that keep schedules full while controlling costs.
Strategic objectives: sustainable growth without compromising patient experience
Marketplace's leadership team is focused on building an operating model that can scale despite rising labor costs and tightening reimbursement.
Their goals include:
- Identifying and implementing initiatives that make the organization more efficient
- Preventing the buildup of administrative work through recruiting, staffing, and process design
- Controlling costs while ensuring consistent, high-level patient service and sustainable growth of visits occurred
"My primary objectives are to drive operational efficiency and cost control without compromising quality, while ensuring consistent, high-level patient service and sustainable growth. I am responsible for building systems that optimize staffing, scheduling, reimbursement, and overhead, empowering leaders to manage performance through clear metrics and accountability, and maintaining a culture that delivers excellent patient experiences."
"Improving the show rate of our patients and minimizing the load this places on the admin team."
How Marketplace historically pursued operational efficiency
Marketplace has long taken a disciplined, "enterprise ops" approach to running a PT organization. Their strategy blends staffing, process design, and technology adoption.
Staffing for immediate coverage (with an obvious ceiling)
When task volume spikes, one typical solution is to hire. Marketplace did that when necessary, building separate administrative functions for different task groups to keep operations moving.
But this approach has a structural limit: payroll scales linearly, and complexity compounds.
"The hiring approach increases payroll and complexity rather than solving the root problem."
Company-wide process design and centralized task management
Marketplace also built repeatable processes and deployed them across clinics. For example, they used centralized spreadsheets to coordinate hundreds of outbound tasks tied to follow-up scheduling, waitlists, and intake.
The advantage: leadership could see where bottlenecks were building and redeploy resources where needed.
A culture of technology adoption
Marketplace has consistently invested in tools to improve operational performance. They were among the first customers to sign up for WebPT during the transition to web-based EMRs, and implemented supporting systems including centralized VOIP, Google Enterprise, AI documentation, electronic verification of benefits, billing optimization solutions, website chat, and SMS across locations.
"As Director of Business Development, my focus is identifying and implementing initiatives that make the organization more efficient as a whole.... However, the volume of tedious, repetitive tasks made that extremely difficult. Removing or automating those tasks is critical so our teams can focus on patients and higher complexity work."
Even with strong operations and a modern stack, Marketplace ran into a new constraint: the software layer wasn't keeping up with the reality of enterprise-level PT task volume.
The core problem: sustaining growth while administrative costs rise and technology stagnates
Marketplace's leadership team saw pressure building from multiple directions at once:
- Labor costs rising faster than reimbursements
- Increasing administrative burden imposed by payers and operational complexity
- An EMR ecosystem that required humans to perform too many repetitive workflows manually
They identified that their biggest operational bottlenecks were increasingly tied to gaps in their technology stack.
"There were so many gaps. Non functioning wait lists. Fake patient scheduling portal (placeholders only). Automated patient outreach, etc..."
"Reimbursements are tight. Automating repetitive tasks is no longer optional, it's essential to controlling costs and allowing teams to focus on patient care."
Two bottlenecks stood out
1) Scheduling burden and "phone tag"
Keeping schedules full required constant manual work: calling patients, confirming, rescheduling, filling cancellations, and ensuring patients didn't fall through the cracks.
2) Intake and referral data entry backlog (a silent revenue leak)
Separately, Marketplace was dealing with a compounding intake problem that many practices feel but few can quantify: the delay between a referral arriving and a patient being contacted. Even with a large team dedicated to intake, they struggled to keep up.
"We have 7 New Patient coordinators working on data entry and no matter what we do we are always 2-3 weeks behind, so by the time that we reach out to patients it's been 4 weeks since we received their referral."
That delay has real consequences: missed patients, missed starts, and a heavier workload to recover patients who might have scheduled sooner.
Why the existing stack couldn't solve it
A major issue was that many tools were designed to be used manually by humans, often with weak integrations and limited automation capabilities.
"All of these systems require training high functioning employees to perform time intensive tasks. Unfortunately, our payroll costs keep going up every year much faster than our reimbursement rates."
Marketplace tried to solve the integration problem directly-at significant cost.
"We spent over $100K trying to do a massive integration between WebPT and Salesforce and in the end what was promised did not even come close to working. Other than that we had implemented every single operational efficiency we could think of."
Eventually, frustration with outages and administrative limitations pushed Marketplace to seriously evaluate switching EMRs.
"At the time, we were actively struggling with administrative burden and already thinking about AI solutions, but we didn't know who could realistically help... WebPT was experiencing frequent outages that were disrupting scheduling and daily operations."
But demo after demo, they found the same pattern: most platforms recorded work; they didn't remove it.
"Most platforms helped us document and track information, but they didn't actively reduce workload or improve workflows. Software felt reactive instead of proactive, and it often created additional work for staff rather than removing it."
What they saw in Penciled: automation without an EMR replacement
Marketplace first learned about Penciled when they were already skeptical of big promises and "rip-and-replace" platforms. What stood out immediately was that Penciled could create leverage while working alongside WebPT instead of forcing an EMR swap.
"What drew me towards Penciled was the authenticity of Shawn's intro email. It was short but he touched on a key pain point that we were experiencing which was frustration with the capabilities of our current EMR system, WebPT."
Marketplace also felt the Penciled team was unusually transparent-especially important after prior integration failures.
"Meeting Shawn stood out immediately. He was passionate about the product but also very realistic about what Penciled could and couldn't do. That transparency built trust. What really captured our attention was how well they understood WebPT and how closely they worked with existing EMRs instead of trying to replace them."
"I could tell right after the first meeting that Shawn and his team had an understanding of the PT world and the obstacles we face. It didn't feel performative what Shawn was selling... it felt authentic..."
Why they signed up: protect profitability by addressing the two biggest threats
Marketplace wasn't buying software for novelty, they were buying operational leverage against two compounding threats: rising payroll and preventable missed visits.
"Penciled had an answer to the two problems that were plaguing us. Exploding payroll costs and no shows. If we continued on our current trajectory it was only a matter of time until our profitability disappeared."
In the short term, the "no-brainer" starting point was the waitlist.
"Originally we signed up to utilize the waitlist since WebPT's waitlist does not work properly and we were using Google Sheets to track waitlisted patients. We weren't having great success with our staff actually working the lists and even when they did, patients were not answering our calls. Automating the waitlist was a no-brainer for us."
And beyond waitlist automation, Marketplace saw a much bigger upside: a path to materially changing their cost structure.
"We felt that Penciled would, in the very near future, have services to drastically change our entire administrative process with the ultimate goal of reducing our administrative costs by up to 50%."
Implementation: complex scheduling rules plus a phased rollout to create value quickly
Marketplace's scheduling requirements are sophisticated. Even with a direct integration to WebPT, they needed Penciled to reflect reality, including payer constraints and operational rules.
Among the requirements were:
- Reading from "available block" templates rather than inferring availability from blank calendar whitespace
- Offering time options based on availability type (for example, eval versus follow-up constraints)
- Payer-specific double-booking rules (allowed for some, restricted for others)
- Ensuring certain appointment types (like initial exams) are never double-booked
- Handling operational edge cases like high-priority patients, Medicare patients, and patients with multiple active cases
"Quickly after we signed up Penciled was already working on the POC portion of the platform but we were hesitant to utilize it because of our complex scheduling rules. The Penciled team quickly came up with solutions to the obstacles we were facing such as high priority patients, medicare patients, patients with two active cases..."
Phase 1: waitlist launch (fastest path to leverage)
Because their scheduling rules were complex, Marketplace launched Penciled's waitlist first, capturing cancellations without staff constantly working call lists.
"The biggest immediate impact was the waitlist automation. Patients were being moved into open slots as cancellations happened, without staff having to manually work task lists. That alone saved a significant amount of time and helped protect visit volume."
What the rollout really took (and why it worked)
The early rollout required real operational work: in the beginning, Marketplace manually added patients and introduced Penciled department-by-department while building internal training.
"Initially we were not able to turn on the auto add for patients so we slowly introduced each department to Penciled and taught them how to manually add in patients. One area that we did struggle with was creating learning material to train our staff..."
Phase 2: full platform rollout
After go-live requirements were completed, Marketplace rolled out the full Penciled platform, including:
- Initial exam scheduling
- Plans of care scheduling and compliance
- Confirmations with cancellations enabled
- Automatic waitlist enrollment integrated into scheduling workflows
By December 2025, the first clinic was fully rolled out, with deployment in progress across the remaining four.
Adoption and change management: the hard part wasn't tech-it was perception
Marketplace wanted to move fast. The biggest internal challenge was organizational alignment, especially because AI tools can be perceived as threatening.
"We wanted to implement Penciled immediately, convincing everyone in the organization was more difficult... We are an organization that changes procedures very regularly so our employees are used to that. The hard part is how employees view AI in an adversarial manner."
Marketplace addressed this with consistent reinforcement across roles-front desk, operations, and clinicians.
"The key takeaway for other practices is to be open-minded and ensure the entire team is aligned. Penciled works best when everyone, from admin to clinicians, is reinforcing its use."
"Everyone needs to buy in if it's going to work! You need to be ready to pitch this to your staff and dont take NO for an answer... People do not like change, especially if they think it's going to take over their job... their time is more valuable than just playing phone tag..."
Marketplace was also concerned that adoption might be difficult for certain patient demographics. That fear didn't materialize.
"I was skeptical about provider buy in and patient adoption, especially among elderly patients. That concern was quickly proven wrong. Providers were very supportive, and patients (across all age groups) adapted easily and responded positively to how user friendly the platform is."
Results: more visits, fewer holes, and measurable time saved
Bookings velocity
After full rollout, the impact was immediate: Penciled was booking over half of all visits.
Volume lift at Riverwalk (first fully rolled-out clinic)
Marketplace reported a 14.8% increase in total volumes averaged over 3 months after implementing Penciled at Riverwalk.
By mid-December:
- Over half of visits were being scheduled through Penciled
- 90+ admin hours saved (conservative estimate at one location)
Call volume dropped by 27%
After implementing Penciled, Marketplace also reported a 27% reduction in call volume-a leading indicator that patients were resolving more scheduling needs without calling in and that front office load was compressing.
Why it matters that visits are booked through Penciled (not manually)
At first glance, it's easy to assume that if the front office could book most of these visits anyway, it shouldn't matter where they're booked. Marketplace's leadership saw it differently: the advantage wasn't volume. It was leverage, changing the cost structure of the business by replacing repetitive human labor with a scalable system.
"What changes when visits are booked through Penciled instead of manually isn't just volume-it's leverage. Most quality PT businesses can create volume. In a physical therapy business, labor is the single largest and least flexible cost, so every hour spent on a task that can be automated is an hour permanently removed from higher-value work. When a front office team is spending 30-40 hours a week scheduling, confirming, rescheduling, and following up, that time is effectively 'locked' at an hourly wage with no scalability. Penciled converts that fixed labor into a scalable system that operates 24/7 at a fraction of the cost, without adding headcount.
When Penciled books over 50% of our visits and eventually much more, it fundamentally changes the cost structure of the business. Those hours are no longer required just to maintain the same visit volume, which means we don't have to hire additional staff as we grow-and in many cases, we can reallocate existing team members to higher-impact work like patient experience, retention, referrals, and problem resolution. That's where revenue protection and growth actually come from. Owners often worry that AI adds cost to achieve the same outcome, but in reality, it removes the most expensive bottleneck in the operation: human time spent on repeatable tasks. That shift is what allows us to scale efficiently, increase margins, and improve service at the same time."
What changed operationally after becoming a Penciled clinic
Less phone-tag, more self-service, fewer complaints
Marketplace consistently returned to the same patient-centered theme: patients want quick, self-serve scheduling, not hold times and voicemails.
"If I can schedule and cancel my visits by just sending a text... that is HUGE... nobody wants to sit on hold or leave voicemails and play phone tag..."
That shift translated into fewer patient complaints and a better environment for staff.
"Now the patients' complaints are few and far between which has improved not only care for our patients but the environment that our staff work in."
"Penciled honestly feels like an answered prayer... Penciled works, and our patients love it. No more waiting on hold, no more phone tag-just quick, painless scheduling right at their fingertips."
Admin teams shifted from repetitive scheduling to higher-leverage work
Marketplace's teams didn't just save time. Their time moved to better work: patient guidance, issue resolution, and higher-impact operational support.
"Front desk and phone teams shifted from manually scheduling appointments to educating patients on using the platform. Other departments reduced repetitive calling and instead relied on booking links, which saved time and improved efficiency."
"This helps us move through the tasks quicker than before and also gives the patient the ability to see the available slots and make selections on their own rather than going back and forth with one of our team members on the phone for 5-10 minutes."
"Our most conservative estimates show that with increased patient visits we are also saving a minimum of 90 hours of administrative time at this one location."
Operational stability through staffing changes
Marketplace also noted that Penciled helped them maintain stability even during staffing turnover without replacing every position.
"We've seen consistent increases in monthly visit volume, reduced no-shows and cancellations, and greater operational stability despite losing administrative staff due to personal reasons. With Penciled's support, we haven't needed to replace all of those positions, which alone has made the investment worthwhile."
Unexpected downstream impact: increased clinician accountability
Marketplace saw improvements in clinician behavior around discharge timing and note completion because automation increased the importance of upstream data accuracy.
"Our DPT's are now DC'ing patients in a timely manner and completing their notes faster... Now with this automation it is vital that they remain current with their notes in order for the system to work correctly which has sparked a fire under them! Which was something we did not expect."
From "firefighting" to sustainable operations
Marketplace described a clear shift in what the business optimizes for day-to-day.
"Before Penciled, the most important priority was simply keeping patients scheduled so their plan of care wasn't disrupted... Administrative survival was often the focus. Now, the priority has shifted to sustainable operations and consistency... With automation supporting scheduling and communication, we're no longer constantly firefighting."
And because schedules became more stable, leadership could focus on payer strategy and long-term profitability.
"Before Penciled we just wanted to fill up holes in our schedule, now we want a system that can function with 50% of the administrative staff we currently have."
"Before Penciled, it was crucial for us to stay on top of our tasks and actively work to keep the schedules full. Now that Penciled is helping maintain a consistently full schedule, we can shift our focus to higher-level priorities-like phasing out low-reimbursement insurance contracts..."
What this meant for WebPT: Penciled extended their timeline
Marketplace didn't claim Penciled fixed every WebPT problem. But they did credit Penciled with addressing the operational gaps that were pushing them toward a full EMR migration.
"Penciled has absolutely helped us remain on WebPT longer. While not all WebPT issues are within Penciled's control, the automation around reminders, cancellations, and rescheduling has significantly reduced no-shows and short-notice cancellations, some of our biggest frustrations."
"Besides our contract, Penciled is the reason we stayed with WebPT. Period. We have so many EMR's contacting us especially Prompt. We actually feel that our partnership with Penciled puts us ahead of everyone else."
"If it wasn't for Penciled, we would be leaving WebPT by the end of our current contract... They don't seem to be focused on the administrative burden that exists in our field and that is the biggest hurdle that we are up against."
Where Marketplace wants to go next: intake and referral automation
If scheduling was the first major operational hill, Marketplace sees the next one clearly: intake and referral processing.
Marketplace receives extremely high inbound referral volume (including faxed referrals) and sees data entry as a major operational and financial bottleneck.
"Data entry automation!!! We receive around 200 faxes per day, and even with a large admin team, we struggle to keep up. Automating intake and referral workflows would drastically reduce delays in patient contact and eliminate missed opportunities."
Michael summarized the top product priority in direct terms:
"100% without a doubt we need new patient demographics automatically imported into Penciled. This is our #1 goal for Penciled right now. I estimated that it will raise our profitability by 3-4% a year."
This next chapter matters because it frames Penciled not as a scheduling solution, but as the foundation for an end-to-end operational system-from referral to intake to scheduling to plan-of-care completion.
Advice from Marketplace to other PT clinics evaluating AI + automation vendors
Marketplace's advice themes were consistent:
- prioritize transparency and realism
- treat adoption as change management
- keep pushing workflow improvement
- plan for a future where efficiency is a survival strategy
"Transparency, I want to know the cold hard truth... Can you do what I'm asking or not?"
"Consistently look for ways to improve your current workflows. Ask yourself, can we do this better? Faster?"
"If AI is not the answer to increased efficiency, what is your plan?"
And Marketplace's view of industry consolidation is blunt:
"Those companies that can be more productive with lower payroll costs than their peers will survive and the others will be bought out or fade away."
Was it worth it?
Marketplace's answer was unequivocal.
"100% yes! It was worth it! Reaching patients in a way that is convenient for them is the #1 struggle that we were facing, having this tool available has made a huge positive impact to the lives we serve."
"Penciled is the most exciting thing that has happened to our organization in many years and the only solution we have to combat the mountain of work imposed on us by insurance companies while still providing a high level of service we expect of our organization. It is allowing us to do the tasks we only dreamed of doing at a fraction of the employee costs. Filling up the holes in our schedule while taking massive amounts of responsibilities off of our employees' plates."
"The team at Penciled has blown us away! They made promises and performed beyond those promises. We are now seeing how powerful Penciled is. It has changed how our practice operates on the admin side by greatly reducing the load it places on them just to get patients on the schedule. Our patients have been so happy with the new scheduling system."

